Could water really have a memory?
The news that the number of prescriptions for homeopathic medicines written by GPs in England has nearly halved in just two years coincides with the 20th anniversary of a seminal scientific paper on the subject.
Twenty years ago, in the summer of 1988, the science world was rocked by one of the most controversial research papers ever published in the highly-respected journal Nature.
According to a charismatic French scientist named Jacques Benveniste, pure water could somehow remember what it had previously contained.
Benveniste had started with a substance that caused an allergic reaction, he diluted it over and over again until there was nothing left except water, and then he observed that the pure water still managed to trigger an allergic reaction when it was added to living cells.
If the experiment was correct then it would mean rewriting the laws of physics and chemistry.
Moreover, the research would have a major impact on the credibility of homeopathy, because it is a form of alternative medicine that relies on remedies made by diluting the key curative ingredient over and over again until that ingredient has disappeared.
Even Benveniste was shocked by the implications of his own work.
“It was like shaking your car keys in the Seine at Paris and then discovering that water taken from the mouth of the river would start your car!”
Supernatural powers
John Maddox, editor of Nature, realised that Benveniste’s research would be controversial, so it was accompanied by a disclaimer similar to one that had been run when he published research about Uri Geller’s supposed supernatural powers.
It said: “Editorial reservation: Readers of this article may share the incredulity of the many referees … Nature has therefore arranged for independent investigators to observe repetitions of the experiments.”
The investigation team was led by Maddox himself, and he was joined by chemist Walter Stewart and James Randi, a magician, who had a reputation for debunking extraordinary claims.
Unfortunately for Benveniste, the investigators soon discovered that the results in his laboratory were unreliable.
The three of them went on to publish a report explaining how Benveniste’s assistants were being subconsciously selective in the way that they interpreted their data.
They said: “We believe that experimental data have been uncritically assessed and their imperfections inadequately reported.”
Benvensiste gradually moved out of academia as a result of the Nature debacle, but right up to his death in 2004 he maintained that his research was valid and that he was being ignored by a blinkered scientific establishment.
Twenty years after his research was published, perhaps now is the ideal time to asses his long-term impact on the debate surrounding ultra-dilute solutions and homeopathy.
Was he an unrecognized genius who was ahead of his time or was he a deluded scientist who failed to see that his research deeply flawed?
First of all, it is worth noting that there have been many attempts to reproduce Benveniste’s experiments - occasionally there are positive results, but they are neither consistent nor convincing, and in any case these are countered by several negative results.
For example, the BBC science series Horizon attempted to test Benveniste’s claims in 2002, and the conclusion was announced by Professor Martin Bland, of St George’s Hospital Medical School.
He said: “There’s absolutely no evidence at all to say that there is any difference between the solution that started off as pure water and the solution that started off with the histamine [an allergen].”
Phenomenon
Similarly, Benveniste started a spin-off company called DigiBio, which claimed that water could not only have a memory, but that this memory could be digitized, transmitted via email and reintroduced into another sample of water, which in turn could have an impact on living cells.
The US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) tested DigiBio’s claim and came to the following conclusion: “Our team found no replicable effects from digital signals.”
Nevertheless, Benveniste’s research continues to be very influential among many homeopaths, such as Alex Tournier, the founding director of the Homeopathy Research Institute.
He said: “Benveniste was a very inspiring and dedicated scientist, who at the very apogee of his career at the French National Institute for Health and Medical Research, was ready to put his reputation on the line to report a phenomenon he didn’t understand: homeopathic dilutions.
“Homeopathy is still not understood, however his efforts started a new era of rigorous scientific investigation of the field.”
Other homeopaths are convinced by Benveniste’s idea of digital homeopathy and are even willing to sell such remedies over the internet.
Some might argue that, as there are over 200 clinical trials, but still no convincing evidence that homeopathy is effective for treating any condition, the idea that digitized homeopathy can help patients is fanciful.
But for $1,000 you could go online and buy yourself a digital homeopathy software kit and start treating yourself and others today.
Serious question marks remain over the Benveniste paper, but what is not in doubt is that its influence is still powerful and profound 20 years on.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
Хотелось бы видеть надпись to be continied
I love Dean, he had the charm of not taking order from the Heavan when it doesn’t make sense, however he appears to belief his father’s order even when he had the doubt.. may be he have more trust in family than God!
I was clueless that there was a great deal to know about blog. Now I want to drop by your blog more regularly to see what other things there are here!
weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee?
Great blog post.Really looking forward to read more.
I really fondness the matter to you shared. Thank you pro rearrangement.
Heya¡my very first comment on your site. ,I have been reading your blog for a while and thought I would completely pop in and drop a friendly note. . It is great stuff indeed. I also wanted to ask..is there a way to subscribe to your site via email?
Substantially, the post is in reality the best on this precious topic. I agree with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your incoming updates. Saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c clarity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay abreast of any updates. Pleasant work and much success in your business enterprize Kenmore Water Filter
I was looking for a meds site when I came across your post in a google search. I agree you with your post completely. Couldn’t of said it better myself.
text-based content? Is actually doing this under creative commons?
Wonderful work,webmaster,decent design!
Being a new blogger, I would like to tell you that you have given me much knowledge about it. Thanks for everything.
Hello! We are checking for upcoming authors, would you be curious? This situation probably won’t get you prosperous except there is an appealing pay out and if you sincerely appreciate penning then now this gig is for you.
Good day! I correlated to your writing yet I did not gain a trackback. Might you show us what is occurring?
Hi! Can easily I move your blog posts in Pdf structure? I would like it in my job.
I’m truly right here to aid, you’ll need to moderate reviews right here. For crying out loud.
Как раз то что искал.Спасибо, если можно, детальнее раскройте всю тему сообщения. Также интересуют приближенные темы.
Как раз то что искал.Спасибо, если можно, детальнее раскройте всю тему сообщения. Также интересуют приближенные темы. Вот еще сайт про гороскопы прикольный http://goroskop.freetzi.com/
I`ve get this source from my friend, I am testing it now and I`m very suprised with the results, really huge traffic and big conversion to sales. Find out how it is possible ,this Idea is amazing, just click on my name, testi it and tell your friends. It really works !
Your web site is simply showing drawbacks on my Chrome browser.
You will find spam comments on your blog.
Hi. I’m searching for guests affiliate marketers to the web site my staff may be building. If you’re fascinated, you know where to achieve me personally.
placing? Might be this specific under creative commons?
There are spam reviews in your weblog. Further, your blog is always showing errors on my Safari browser.
Hi. I am searching for guests writers towards the web site my employees is building. If you’re fascinated, you know exactly where to reach me.
Thank you for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about information and love learning more on this. If possible,it was very helpful for me.
Hey – nice blog, just looking around some sites, seems a fairly nice platform you are applying. I’m currently using Wordpress for a few of my blogs but shopping to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Something in particular you’d recommend about it?
I love to learning more on this topic if possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information?
I truly enjoyed this. It was extremely educational and useful. I will return to check on upcoming posts
This is Awesome! Thank you so much.
Pretty very good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have very enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post once again soon.
Good blog article. I arrived on the internet to discover exactly where to watch nfl football games and somehow came across your blog. You should write a post on how to watch football online because it’s a well-known subject correct now. I utilized Google and only arrived up with this website http://www.p2p4ufootball.com but require some much more choices.
There is a vast amount of information on the blog you’ve started. Thanks.
wow this seems truly great do you thoughts if i share this?
Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel can find any information in article and discus forum
There is a vast amount of information on the blog you’ve started. Thanks.
Your web site provides a lot of distinctive insights and info. I haven’t truly assumed about it like that.
I just found your blog on Ask Jeeves, a really good read.
Great post. Very refreshing given all the duplicate content out there. Thanks for doing something original.
Just to let you know..
. your website looks very strange in Mozilla on a Mac
I watch football online each day during football time of year. I love http://howtowatchfootball.com/index.php because it helps you watch live NFL football games online for free. No other site gives as much information about how you can watch football online for totally free. You ought to examine it out if you’re a NFL fan and want to watch live NFL games online during football season.
There is a website http://howtowatchfootball.com/index.php which is about how to watch live nfl football online. I believe it’s the greatest site on the internet to assist you watch football on the internet for totally free. No other site about how you can watch nfl football on the internet is as good as this website.
i get tired of all the spam on here, really, get a life people, i mean, don’t you have anything better to do than spam an innocent blog??? really.. take care of the spam please. anyway, good post and keep it up.
A situation that I have always been serious about excellent to read your actual standpoint. I was in fact speculating any fishermen on here then look into this website out comprehensive fantastic knowledge. Simply put i have been heading back to it consistently. Merely like this website
Wonderful facts, several many thanks to the author.
путаны шлюхи проститутки индивидуалки калининград я ищу интим знакомства секс досуг иркутск интим дешево dosug sz выбери себе развлечение медсестра интим амстердам интим салон узбечки досуг прститутки индивидуалки шлюхи г казани интим знакомства в орле интимные знакомства в пензе проститутки красноярск проститутки красноярска индивидуалки www досуг ru досуг в самаре досуг в московской области досуг в мариуполе шлюхи москвы за 1000 рублей дешевые проститутки уфы досуг в краснодаре вип интим досуг
Upon looking through this a couple of questions arose. Let me think it over before placing them here mainly because I really don’t want to worry you with something I could have without difficulty track down in Yahoo and google.